Nucleus Prep
BlogThe application process

Who should write my letters of recommendation?

By SashankMS1 at a U.S. MD program

Published Updated

The classic combination is two science professors, one non-science professor, and a physician or a clinical or research supervisor who's worked with you directly. Many schools also accept a single committee letter instead, if your school offers one.

Pick people who know you well, not the biggest title you can find. A detailed letter from the professor who ran your small seminar usually beats a vague one from a department chair who barely remembers you. Ask early, and give each writer your CV and a draft of your personal statement so they have something real to work with.

Letters are the one part of your application you don't write yourself, which makes choosing and preparing your writers really important. Here's how to do it well.

The types of letters AMCAS accepts

Letter type What it is When it fits
Committee letter A letter from your school's pre-health committee or advisor, representing your school's evaluation of you If your school offers one, many medical schools prefer it
Letter packet A set of individual letters collected and sent by your pre-health office, without an evaluative committee letter If your school collects letters but doesn't write a committee letter
Individual letter A letter from one writer If your school has no committee, or for extra letters like a physician or research mentor

Committee letter

What it is
A letter from your school's pre-health committee or advisor, representing your school's evaluation of you
When it fits
If your school offers one, many medical schools prefer it

Letter packet

What it is
A set of individual letters collected and sent by your pre-health office, without an evaluative committee letter
When it fits
If your school collects letters but doesn't write a committee letter

Individual letter

What it is
A letter from one writer
When it fits
If your school has no committee, or for extra letters like a physician or research mentor

AMCAS lets you create up to 10 letter entries, and each committee letter, packet, or individual letter counts as one entry. That doesn't mean schools want 10 letters. The cap exists so you can send different letters to different schools.

The standard combination

If you're not using a committee letter, most schools want something like:

  • Two science professors who taught you in a class with a letter grade. Biology, chemistry, physics, or math.
  • One non-science professor, from any field.
  • One or two additional letters, from a physician you shadowed or worked with, a clinical supervisor, a research mentor, or an employer.

Requirements vary. Some schools want a specific number from science faculty, some require a letter from a research mentor if you did research, and some DO schools want a letter from a DO. Check each school in the MSAR.

Choosing the right writers

The best letters come from people who can describe you in detail. A good writer:

  • Knows you personally, beyond your grade.
  • Has seen you work over time, in class, in a lab, or in a clinical setting.
  • Can give specific examples of your skills and character.
  • Will write a strong letter. It's fine to ask directly: "Do you feel you know me well enough to write a strong letter?"

A famous name doesn't help if the letter is generic. Committees read thousands of letters and can tell the difference between "a good student" and "one of the most thoughtful students I've taught in 10 years, and here's why."

Building relationships early

You can't get a strong letter from a professor you've never talked to. Start building relationships in your first two years:

  • Go to office hours, even when you don't have a specific problem.
  • Participate in class, especially in smaller courses and seminars.
  • Take more than one class with professors you connect with.
  • Stay in touch after the class ends, with an occasional email or update.
  • Do great work in research or clinical roles where a supervisor can see you over months.

For research mentors and physicians, the same applies. A year working with someone gives them a lot to write about. Here's more on research and shadowing.

How to ask

  1. Ask in person or by video if you can, and give writers at least a month, ideally more.
  2. Ask early in the year you apply, or right after a class or job ends while you're fresh in their mind. Some letters can be written early and held until you apply.
  3. Give them a packet: your CV, a draft of your personal statement, the courses you took with them and your grades, a few things you hope they'll mention, and instructions for submitting.
  4. Waive your right to see the letter. AMCAS asks whether you waive access. Waiving tells schools the letter is candid, and most applicants do.
  5. Send a gentle reminder a week or two before your target date.
  6. Thank them, and let them know how your cycle goes.

Common mistakes

  • Asking someone who barely knows you because of their title.
  • Asking too late, which can delay your application.
  • Not checking requirements for specific schools.
  • Sending too many letters. More isn't better. Send what each school asks for, and make every one strong.
  • Forgetting that reapplicants need new letter submissions. AMCAS requires letters to be submitted again each cycle.

Your letter plan

  1. List potential writers from classes, research, clinical work, and jobs.
  2. Check your school's pre-health office to see if they write committee letters.
  3. Check requirements at each school on your list.
  4. Choose four to six writers who know you well, covering science, non-science, and clinical or research.
  5. Ask early and give each writer a packet.
  6. Track every letter in AMCAS and follow up as needed.

If you're not sure whether your letter writers are the right mix for your school list, that's a good question for a free strategy session. Getting every piece of your application to line up, letters included, is what admissions advising is for.


Letter types, the 10-letter limit, and reapplicant rules are from the AAMC's AMCAS letters of evaluation guidance for the 2027 cycle. School requirements vary, so check the MSAR and each school's site. Nucleus Prep doesn't guarantee scores or acceptances.