Nucleus Prep
BlogThe application process

How do secondary applications work?

By SashankMS1 at a U.S. MD program

Published Updated

After your primary application is verified, schools send secondary applications, often to almost everyone who applied. Secondaries have school-specific essay prompts and usually a fee, which varies by school.

The rule of thumb is to send each one back within about two weeks. Write answers to the common prompts in the spring, before they arrive: diversity, a significant challenge, "why us," and explaining a gap year. That way you're not writing 20 schools' essays from scratch on a two-week clock.

Secondaries are where a lot of applicants lose momentum. Here's how they work and how to stay ahead of them.

The common prompts

Most schools ask some version of the same few questions. Here's what they're really asking and how to approach each.

Prompt What they're really asking How to approach it
Why our school? Do you know us, and do you fit? Name specific programs, values, or opportunities that match your experiences
Diversity or perspective What will you add to our class? Your background, experiences, or viewpoint, with a specific example
A challenge or failure How do you handle setbacks? What happened, what you did, and what you learned
Gap year or "what are you doing now?" Are you staying engaged? Your current activities and what they're teaching you
Anything else? Is there context we need? Use it only if something important isn't covered elsewhere

Why our school?

What they're really asking
Do you know us, and do you fit?
How to approach it
Name specific programs, values, or opportunities that match your experiences

Diversity or perspective

What they're really asking
What will you add to our class?
How to approach it
Your background, experiences, or viewpoint, with a specific example

A challenge or failure

What they're really asking
How do you handle setbacks?
How to approach it
What happened, what you did, and what you learned

Gap year or "what are you doing now?"

What they're really asking
Are you staying engaged?
How to approach it
Your current activities and what they're teaching you

Anything else?

What they're really asking
Is there context we need?
How to approach it
Use it only if something important isn't covered elsewhere

Other common ones include teamwork, an ethical dilemma, a time you worked with someone different from you, and your career goals.

How secondaries work

Timing. Secondaries usually start arriving in late June or July, after your primary is verified and sent to schools. They keep coming through the summer.

Who gets them. Many schools send secondaries to almost every applicant. Others screen first, so getting a secondary from them is a good sign.

Fees. Most schools charge a secondary fee, and it varies by school. Many schools waive it for applicants in the AAMC Fee Assistance Program, so check each school's policy.

Length. Prompts can be anywhere from a few sentences to a full page. Some schools have one essay, others have five or more.

Why speed matters

Most schools use rolling admissions. They usually won't review your application until your secondary is in, and interview spots fill as the cycle goes on.

The common rule is to return each secondary within about two weeks. Faster isn't always better if it costs quality, but sitting on secondaries for a month can push you behind other applicants. Here's more on why applying early matters.

If you applied to 25 schools, that could mean 25 sets of essays in about two months. That's why pre-writing matters so much.

Pre-writing in the spring

You can't know every prompt, but many repeat from year to year. Before AMCAS opens:

  1. Look up last year's prompts for every school on your list. Many students share them, and many schools reuse them.
  2. Write strong drafts of the common ones: why medicine, diversity, challenge, gap year, and your career goals.
  3. Make multiple lengths of each, like 150, 300, and 500 words, so you can adapt quickly.
  4. Research each school and make notes on its mission, programs, and what fits you.

When secondaries arrive, you'll mostly be adapting and tailoring, not starting from scratch.

Writing "why us" well

"Why our school" is the prompt where generic answers hurt most. A good answer:

  • Names specific things about the school: a program, clinic, curriculum feature, community, or mission.
  • Connects each one to your experiences. If you've worked with underserved communities, point to the school's student-run clinic and explain why it matters to you.
  • Avoids copy-paste mistakes. Mentioning the wrong school's name is more common than you'd think, and it's very noticeable.

If you can't find anything specific to say about a school, that might be a sign it shouldn't be on your list. Here's how many schools to apply to.

Avoiding burnout

Secondary season is intense. A few things help:

  • Keep a tracker with each school's prompts, deadline, fee, and status.
  • Work in batches by prompt type.
  • Set a daily goal, like finishing one or two schools a day.
  • Get feedback on your core essays, then reuse what works.
  • Don't let quality drop at the end. The last school on your list deserves your best essay too.

Your secondary plan

  1. In the spring: collect last year's prompts and pre-write the common essays.
  2. When you submit your primary: set up a tracker and research notes for each school.
  3. When secondaries arrive: tailor and submit each within about two weeks.
  4. Pay attention to "why us": make it specific every time.
  5. After submitting: start preparing for interviews. Here's how to prepare.

Tailoring secondaries to each school's mission pays off far more than reusing one generic answer, and it's a big part of what we help with in admissions advising. If you're mid-cycle and falling behind, a free strategy session can help you prioritize.